Challenger Disaster

When NASA released the transcripts of the crew-to-ground communication, The New York Times sued NASA to also have access to the actual audio tape. Recovered in the ocean, the tape had not been released for public use. NASA wanted to protect the privacy of the families, among other things.

The District Court initially held the tapes should be turned over. With both sides appealing different rulings, the case ultimately ended up with the United States Supreme Court. The justices directed the District Court Judge to rule whether the privacy of the crew families would be invaded were the tapes to be released. Weighing the right of the public to know, and the right of privacy possessed by the families, the Court ruled against The New York Times. The audio tapes have never been released.

But litigation did not start, and end, with the transcript dispute. The families also filed suit - but for very different reasons.